Why most new lawns fail: it’s what’s underneath

When a new lawn fails, people usually blame the turf. Wrong variety, bad batch, not enough water. Most of the time the turf was fine. The problem was underneath it: the levels, the drainage, the soil, or the watering. Get those right and almost any good turf will thrive. Get them wrong and even the best roll of Sir Walter will struggle.

1. The levels weren't right

A lawn needs a gentle, even fall so water runs off instead of sitting in low spots. If the ground has dips, the low spots stay wet and the high spots dry out. You end up with a patchwork of soggy and brown, and mowing scalps the bumps.

Levels need to be set before anything else goes down, with the fall running away from the house and towards somewhere the water can go.

2. Turf was laid on compacted ground

New house sites and old yards are often compacted hard by machinery, cars or years of foot traffic. Roots can't push into compacted ground, so they stay in the top few centimetres. A shallow-rooted lawn looks fine in spring and burns off in the first heatwave.

Compacted ground needs breaking up before the sand/soil base and turf go on top.

There’s a difference between the two layers: the old ground underneath needs ripping up, but the new base on top needs compacting properly. Loose sand or soil can drop a surprising amount once it’s compacted and rained on. That’s why so many lawns end up sitting below the paving: level on the day the contractor left, sunk after the first big downpour. Shaype compacts and wets the base before any turf goes down. If it drops, we top it up and compact again, so we know the height is final.

3. Not enough of the right base

Turf needs a decent depth of good material underneath to root into. Laying it on a thin skim over clay, rubble or builder’s fill gives the roots nowhere to go. Turf suppliers generally recommend at least 100 mm of quality underlay under new turf, and more is better.

We prefer to lay turf on a sand/soil base. It drains freely, it levels and compacts evenly, and the roots grow straight down into it instead of sitting in wet, heavy clay.

Huw was called to a lawn in Toorak that looked green and fine from the street. But it was always fluffy, the owner couldn't mow it down, it was boggy, and it stopped growing in winter. When he lifted it, the turf had been laid straight onto clay, rock and pebbles. If the budget is tight, a bag of gypsum worked in before the turf goes down is a cheap way to help break up clay underneath.

4. The drainage was ignored

Much of Melbourne is heavy clay, which holds water and drains slowly. On a clay site, a lawn with no way to shed water will be waterlogged all winter. Waterlogged roots rot, the turf thins out, and weeds and moss move in.

Sometimes the fix is just better levels. Sometimes it needs subsoil drainage under the lawn. Either way, it has to happen before the turf goes down. (We cover the warning signs in Signs your backyard has a drainage problem.)

5. The watering was wrong

New turf needs a lot of water for the first few weeks while it roots in, then much less, more deeply. Two common mistakes:

  • Too little early on. New turf sitting on the surface dries out fast, and the edges shrink and brown first.

  • Too much, too often, for too long. Short daily watering keeps roots shallow, and a constantly wet surface invites disease.

An irrigation system with sprays laid out to cover the whole lawn evenly takes the guesswork out of it, as long as the run times are set properly and adjusted as the lawn establishes.

6. The irrigation went in after the lawn

If you want irrigation, it should go in before the turf. Trenching through a new lawn to add sprinklers later means cutting up the turf you've just paid for. Planning the irrigation, drainage and lawn as one job means everything goes in once, in the right order.

7. The turf didn't suit the spot

Often, the person laying the turf hasn’t worked out where the sun falls in that yard across the year. Some varieties need a lot of sun, others a lot of water. That Toorak lawn was also a summer turf laid in a shaded area. It held on for about 12 months, then started dying. Matching the variety to the sun and shade is half the job.

What a lawn built properly looks like

When we build a lawn, the order is always the same:

  1. Set the levels and falls

  2. Sort out drainage where it's needed

  3. Break up compacted ground and bring in a good sand/soil base

  4. Choose a turf that suits your sun and shade

  5. Install the irrigation

  6. Lay the turf and get the watering set up for establishment

It's the part of the job nobody sees once it's finished. It's also the part that decides whether the lawn is still looking good in five years.

Planning a new lawn?

Shaype supplies and lays turf as part of full landscape builds right across Melbourne, with the earthworks, drainage and irrigation done properly underneath. See our residential landscaping, or book a site visit and we'll look at what your yard needs.

Huw Williams

Huw Williams is the founder and director of Shaype Projects, a Melbourne landscape construction, earthworks and irrigation business based in Moorabbin. He quotes, walks the site and runs every job through to handover.

https://www.shaypeprojects.com.au/about
Next
Next

Signs your backyard has a drainage problem